How to set up default answer choice for single answer, multiple choice based on previous response

Hi all. I'd like to set up a series of two multiple choice questions (single answer) with the same 4-point scale picklist. I would like the second question's default answer choice to be what the respondent selected in the question before it. But, I still want the other three points to be shown.

The context is a [Definitely/Likely/Unlikely/Definitely not] question that asks for a respondent's likelihood of doing something. Then in the next question, I add a piece of information to the description, and ask the respondent to either change their answer given the new piece of information, or if their answer has not changed despite the new information, to leave it as the default selection (their selected choice in the first question).

Is this in Qualtrics' functionality that I'm missing, and if not, does anyone have code I could use to achieve this? Thank you all in advance.