HTML only working on one choice of multiple choice question

Hello,
I have a multiple choice question in my survey with three choices, where I would like to show additional information when the survey taker clicks on the information button. I've been able to add the required buttons to all three choices. However, the text I want to display when the info button is clicked is only showing up under the first choice. I'm using the same code for the second choice, just a different text, but it is not displaying when the info button is clicked.
I have added JS to the question and used this: jQuery("#button").click(function() {
  jQuery("#infodiv").toggle();
});

The HTML I have used that works for the first choice is: a domestic applicant ℹ

[...],
where I put the text I want to display where the [...] are.
Would anybody have any advice why the same code is not working on the second choice?

Thank you so much!