Skip Logic

I set up a test of skip logic where there are three options (1, 2 and 3) in the first question, each of which skips the respondent to question 2, 3, or 4, depending on which of the options he or she chooses. I would like for the respondent who chooses option 1 to only see question 2. But, when I tested it by selecting option 1, I went to question 2 but could also see questions 3 and 4. Can someone tell me how I can set it up so the respondent only sees the one question I want them to see? Thank you.